The arbitrary detention of two Liberian journalists, Elvis Gono of the Liberia Broadcasting System and Philip Gbana of Classic FM, for three nights at the Kakata Central Prison has sparked concerns over judicial overreach and potential abuse of power within the Margibi County judicial system. The journalists’ ordeal began on February 10, 2025, when Judge Golda A. Bona Elliot of the 13th Judicial Circuit Court ordered their detention on charges of “Contempt of Court.” The order stemmed from a request by Margibi County Attorney Deddeh Wilson, who alleged that the journalists had failed to produce a crime suspect for whom they had acted as guarantors since September 2025. This narrative, however, is contested by the journalists, who maintain they were never officially notified of the need to produce the suspect. Their detention occurred while they were covering the opening of the February Term of Court, highlighting the seemingly opportunistic nature of their arrest. The incident underscores the precarious position journalists often face while carrying out their duties, particularly within politically charged environments.
The Press Union of Liberia (PUL), a staunch advocate for press freedom and the rights of journalists, swiftly intervened in the case following the suspect’s apprehension and subsequent remand at the Kakata Central Prison. The PUL’s efforts culminated in the journalists’ release in the early hours of Thursday, February 13, 2025. While expressing relief at their regained freedom, Gono and Gbana were vocal about the injustice they experienced, characterizing their detention as an abuse of judicial power. Their account directly contradicts the official narrative presented by the County Attorney, raising serious questions about the legality and justification of their three-night incarceration. The journalists’ claim that they were never formally requested to produce the suspect further casts doubt on the due process followed in this case, suggesting a potential disregard for their fundamental rights.
The conflicting narratives between the journalists and the Margibi County judicial officials have created a demand for clarity and accountability. The PUL, recognizing the gravity of the situation and its potential implications for press freedom in Liberia, has called for an independent investigation into the circumstances surrounding the detention. This investigation is crucial to ascertain the veracity of the competing claims and determine whether County Attorney Wilson and Public Defender Cllr. Alfred B. Holmes acted within the bounds of their authority or engaged in the abuse of public power. Furthermore, the investigation will seek to clarify the journalists’ role, if any, in the alleged failure to produce the suspect. This inquiry aims not only to address the specific incident but also to establish a precedent that safeguards journalists from undue harassment and unwarranted detention while performing their professional duties.
The incident involving Gono and Gbana underscores the fragile relationship between the media and the judiciary in Liberia. While both institutions play crucial roles in upholding democratic principles and ensuring accountability, instances like this expose underlying tensions and potential for conflict. The PUL’s call for an independent investigation reflects a broader concern about the need for greater transparency and accountability within the judicial system, particularly concerning its interactions with the media. The incident highlights the importance of clear protocols and communication channels between these two vital pillars of a democratic society. A thorough investigation is necessary to rebuild trust and foster a more constructive working relationship.
The PUL, in its advocacy for a robust and independent media landscape, emphasizes the critical role of collaboration and mutual respect between the media and the judiciary. Both entities serve the public interest, albeit through different mechanisms. The media acts as a watchdog, holding power to account and informing the public, while the judiciary interprets and applies the law, ensuring justice and upholding the rule of law. For these systems to function effectively, a healthy balance of power and mutual respect is essential. Incidents like the detention of Gono and Gbana erode this balance and can have a chilling effect on press freedom, potentially discouraging journalists from critically reporting on sensitive issues, particularly those involving the judiciary.
The PUL’s call for professionalism from both the media and the judiciary is a timely reminder of the responsibilities that accompany these roles. Journalists must adhere to ethical standards, ensuring accuracy and fairness in their reporting. Similarly, judicial officials must uphold the principles of due process and respect the rights of all individuals, including journalists. This incident serves as a learning opportunity for both the media and the judiciary in Liberia. By fostering open dialogue and addressing the underlying issues that contribute to such confrontations, both institutions can work towards a more productive and respectful relationship. The outcome of the independent investigation will be a significant step in determining the future trajectory of this relationship and the overall health of press freedom in Liberia. It is in the best interest of all parties involved to ensure a transparent and thorough investigation that addresses the core issues at hand and fosters a more conducive environment for both journalism and the administration of justice.
